Raocorp
(Post Master Sr)
05/07/19 08:59 AM
Garage Floor repair?

Anybody know a good way to repair the garage floor other than tearing it up completely?

The floor in my garage is starting to crumble. Its not horrible just yet but I'd like to fill it before real divots start happening. I know there's that self leveler stuff but thats mostly a liquid and seems somewhat complicated to work with. I'm looking to smooth out the concrete and then possibly lay something down on top to protect it like some kind of like snap tile or something like that. Don't want to spend huge money but maybe $1k should be ok. I want to see whats out there or for some creative ideas. I don't know how to host pics anymore, but even if I did, the car is up on my QuickJack at the moment anyway so I can't even take good pics.


Screamin Type ARGH!
(Post Master Supreme)
05/07/19 09:20 AM
Re: Garage Floor repair?

https://allgaragefloors.com/how-to-grind-garage-floor/
https://www.reddit.com/r/DIY/comments/3ie8nl/what_equipment_do_you_need_to_diamond_grind_a/

you'll prob want to do a grind on it first, prepping it properly will basically make or break your end results. 'cleaning' it helps but doesn't truly prep it nicely for a good finish. or maybe have a company come grind/prep it, clean it, then you lay down whatever finish you want. also consider a vapour barrier too.

polyaspartic or epoxy are your best options for finishes, and they vary in quality and price. both are good with each their own drawbacks.

then you have the snap tile you're thinking of. i wouldn't recommend the snap tile stuff though. think of the harsh winters and salt residue that will come into the garage with all that crap, also the hot summers with hot tires on it. i mean the tiles maybe work better in a place down south IMO, but i don't know your situation re. usage and $ ... so up to you.

https://www.encoregarage.com/Garage-Floor-Coatings-Epoxies-vs-Polyaspartics
https://www.concretenetwork.com/polyaspartic-floor-coatings/comparison.html
http://www.penncoatinc.com/epoxycoatingspolyasparticcoatings/

https://www.armorgarage.com/garage-epoxy-tiles-mats.html
http://blog.bostongarage.com/epoxy-flooring-vs-tiles

i'm having a co. finish my garage this spring/early summer, prob doing epoxy floor, tho poly is tempting.


Senor Eduardo_82
(Post Master Supreme)
05/07/19 09:54 AM
Re: Garage Floor repair?

https://www.princessauto.com/en/detail/30-x-60-ft-heavy-duty-poly-tarp/A-p8648867e

furball
(Post Master Sr)
05/07/19 11:02 AM
Re: Garage Floor repair?

I have a tarp during the winter, held down at the corners with bricks, and rubber anti-slip mats on the sides. In the spring/summer it's just folded in the middle of the garage floor.

 Originally Posted By: Hellen Keller
https://www.princessauto.com/en/detail/30-x-60-ft-heavy-duty-poly-tarp/A-p8648867e


Risky Business
(Post Master Supreme)
05/07/19 11:23 AM
Re: Garage Floor repair?

Not a single piece of advice will be relevant until OP posts pics so we can see the actual condition of the floor.

Tarp away tho, furball is doing it!


Screamin Type ARGH!
(Post Master Supreme)
05/07/19 12:12 PM
Re: Garage Floor repair?

don't do it! IT'S A TARP!

Risky Business
(Post Master Supreme)
05/07/19 12:25 PM
Re: Garage Floor repair?

If you are going to redo your garage I'd recommend porcelain tiles, I did my whole garage in commercial grade porcelain tiles (left overs from a TD bank branch job) and they've been great for 2+ years now. They don't break, strong as fuck and will outlive the garage. You can throw a sledge on them hammer on them, no issues.

People that have issues with tiles are those who get ceramic tiles and don't double butter up on installation.


Screamin Type ARGH!
(Post Master Supreme)
05/07/19 01:29 PM
Re: Garage Floor repair?

#LAVISH

phoenixrage
(Post Master Supreme)
05/07/19 03:55 PM
Re: Garage Floor repair?

PISS ON IT

Simon_the_Pieman
(Post Master Sr)
05/07/19 06:37 PM
Re: Garage Floor repair?

 Originally Posted By: Risky Business
If you are going to redo your garage I'd recommend porcelain tiles, I did my whole garage in commercial grade porcelain tiles (left overs from a TD bank branch job) and they've been great for 2+ years now. They don't break, strong as fuck and will outlive the garage. You can throw a sledge on them hammer on them, no issues.

People that have issues with tiles are those who get ceramic tiles and don't double butter up on installation.


and dont get shiny ones. dealership pretty, but you'll slip all over the place esp in winter.


Raocorp
(Post Master Sr)
05/09/19 08:52 AM
Re: Garage Floor repair?

 Originally Posted By: Risky Business
If you are going to redo your garage I'd recommend porcelain tiles, I did my whole garage in commercial grade porcelain tiles (left overs from a TD bank branch job) and they've been great for 2+ years now. They don't break, strong as fuck and will outlive the garage. You can throw a sledge on them hammer on them, no issues.

People that have issues with tiles are those who get ceramic tiles and don't double butter up on installation.


when I say tiles, I didn't really mean anything that requires being cemented down permanently. I don't think I quite there yet.


Screamin Type ARGH!
(Post Master Supreme)
05/09/19 09:36 AM
Re: Garage Floor repair?

persian rugs work. regular price 1500, for you 1450.

Risky Business
(Post Master Supreme)
05/09/19 12:22 PM
Re: Garage Floor repair?

 Originally Posted By: Raocorp
 Originally Posted By: Risky Business
If you are going to redo your garage I'd recommend porcelain tiles, I did my whole garage in commercial grade porcelain tiles (left overs from a TD bank branch job) and they've been great for 2+ years now. They don't break, strong as fuck and will outlive the garage. You can throw a sledge on them hammer on them, no issues.

People that have issues with tiles are those who get ceramic tiles and don't double butter up on installation.


when I say tiles, I didn't really mean anything that requires being cemented down permanently. I don't think I quite there yet.


I didn't recommend you tile


c2k
(Post Master Supreme)
05/09/19 05:31 PM
Re: Garage Floor repair?

 Originally Posted By: Risky Business
If you are going to redo your garage I'd recommend porcelain tiles, I did my whole garage in commercial grade porcelain tiles (left overs from a TD bank branch job) and they've been great for 2+ years now. They don't break, strong as fuck and will outlive the garage. You can throw a sledge on them hammer on them, no issues.

People that have issues with tiles are those who get ceramic tiles and don't double butter up on installation.


sounds interesting..

pics?


Risky Business
(Post Master Supreme)
05/09/19 05:41 PM
Re: Garage Floor repair?



titty sprinkles
(Post Master Supreme)
05/10/19 02:56 PM
Re: Garage Floor repair?

^seen it in real life and it's sick. also makes me want to take out a RRSP and make a financial plan.

c2k
(Post Master Supreme)
05/10/19 04:26 PM
Re: Garage Floor repair?

Wow that looks amazing. It holds up to just about anything? Even dropping rotors on the floor will not crack?

Risky Business
(Post Master Supreme)
05/10/19 04:47 PM
Re: Garage Floor repair?

Porcelain tiles installed property are stronger than exposed concrete.

You can beat the crap out of them and there are no issues.

https://youtu.be/elJtN6nRlhk


zaius
(Post Master Sr)
05/10/19 06:16 PM
Re: Garage Floor repair?

when i got my place, it was all spalled, pitted concrete from decades of water/salt damage.

what i did was buy a few bags of Mapei Mapem Quick Patch for like $20 each.

https://www.mapei.com/au/en/products-and-solutions/products/detail/mapecem-sup----sup---quickpatch

I mixed it and i tried the best i could to fill in the holes and skim coat it in. the pot life is 20 minutes so you need to work fast.

it still looks terrible cause i'm not that skilled, but at least it isn't rutted out anymore. looks like uneven drywall mud now on my floor. it has lasted me 3 winters already with no peeling.

it's not pretty but it works. for your application, i think if you buy a bag and slim coat, it'll look pretty darn decent.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6rRbqNyi1yI


Raocorp
(Post Master Sr)
05/21/19 09:27 AM
Re: Garage Floor repair?

Some pics:

https://www.dropbox.com/s/ac6ndwq1z78z001/Floor%201.jpg
https://www.dropbox.com/s/m10ueqjt1o425mq/Floor%203.jpg

Sorry, i don't know where to host them so that they are just viewable here.
Those two are pretty representative of the garage. Its not all bad, just parts. Not a fan of grinding the floor down tho, would rather just do a top coat and epoxy over that if possible.


LNXGUY
(Post Master Supreme)
05/21/19 10:48 AM
Re: Garage Floor repair?

Imgur for hosting.

Risky Business
(Post Master Supreme)
05/22/19 09:41 AM
Re: Garage Floor repair?

 Originally Posted By: Raocorp
Some pics:

https://www.dropbox.com/s/ac6ndwq1z78z001/Floor%201.jpg
https://www.dropbox.com/s/m10ueqjt1o425mq/Floor%203.jpg

Sorry, i don't know where to host them so that they are just viewable here.
Those two are pretty representative of the garage. Its not all bad, just parts. Not a fan of grinding the floor down tho, would rather just do a top coat and epoxy over that if possible.


You can use self leveler, but considering that there is paint on your floor you will need to clean/grind the whole thing really well. I don't think there is an affordable solution for this that will last long. You can do a half assed prep job and hope it sticks. If the garage floor doesn't get much use it might work, but I can see it start falling apart within 24 months.

CN: leave it


Screamin Type ARGH!
(Post Master Supreme)
05/22/19 10:16 AM
Re: Garage Floor repair?

 Originally Posted By: Risky Business
 Originally Posted By: Raocorp
Some pics:

https://www.dropbox.com/s/ac6ndwq1z78z001/Floor%201.jpg
https://www.dropbox.com/s/m10ueqjt1o425mq/Floor%203.jpg

Sorry, i don't know where to host them so that they are just viewable here.
Those two are pretty representative of the garage. Its not all bad, just parts. Not a fan of grinding the floor down tho, would rather just do a top coat and epoxy over that if possible.


You can use self leveler, but considering that there is paint on your floor you will need to clean/grind the whole thing really well. I don't think there is an affordable solution for this that will last long. You can do a half assed prep job and hope it sticks. If the garage floor doesn't get much use it might work, but I can see it start falling apart within 24 months.

CN: leave it


+1


Raocorp
(Post Master Sr)
05/22/19 06:56 PM
Re: Garage Floor repair?

I thought about leaving it too but it's a real PITA to move my jack around and just anything that rolls. If I were to grind the floor does one of those tool rental places have such a device? It's a 2 car garage so it won't take more than a day to grind the floor I don't think.....

Could I use the self leveler stuff only on the problem areas? Do do I have to spread it over the entire surface? Honestly if it lasts 24months I'd be happy with that for now cuz I may move depending on what happens with work.


titty sprinkles
(Post Master Supreme)
05/22/19 07:44 PM
Re: Garage Floor repair?

the way i see it, there's 2 ways to have a proper garage floor.

1) tiles like risky

2) professional coating.


Risky Business
(Post Master Supreme)
05/23/19 10:21 AM
Re: Garage Floor repair?

 Originally Posted By: Raocorp
I thought about leaving it too but it's a real PITA to move my jack around and just anything that rolls. If I were to grind the floor does one of those tool rental places have such a device? It's a 2 car garage so it won't take more than a day to grind the floor I don't think.....

Could I use the self leveler stuff only on the problem areas? Do do I have to spread it over the entire surface? Honestly if it lasts 24months I'd be happy with that for now cuz I may move depending on what happens with work.


There is only one way to find out. Yes you can use it on those areas only, clean it well, put the leveler in and see what happens. If you are not moving the car in and out and constantly bringing in salt/slush it might last while. If you don't care about looks it should be fine.


Wildout
(Post Master Jr)
05/24/19 12:24 PM
Re: Garage Floor repair?

Yes, you can rent a floor grinder, but by no means is it on the easier side of the DIY. One of the more demanding jobs I've had. Honestly, I'd just leave it, to do it properly you might as well do a professional coating, but then you're looking at money. Anything else will fail, I've seen it.

Proper floor prep over everything.


jackedUP_hatch
(Jr Member)
05/28/19 06:45 PM
Re: Garage Floor repair?

 Originally Posted By: Risky Business


Nicely done